During the design and manufacturing of electronic products, the quality of the printed circuit board (PCB) directly determines the reliability of the final product. When a circuit board exhibits functional anomalies or performance degradation, how to conduct systematic failure analysis to identify the true root cause is a key concern for many engineers. This article explains the main objectives, common failure modes, analysis procedures, and key considerations of PCB failure analysis.
Why Conduct Failure Analysis
1. Accurately identify the failure symptom
When a circuit board fails, the symptoms may include open circuits, short circuits, abnormally high resistance, signal transmission distortion, or even component burnout. The first step is to determine exactly what has happened.
2. Locate the failure site
Failures may occur in a specific area of the board, on a particular net, at a via, or at a specific solder joint. Analytical techniques are needed to pinpoint the exact location.
3. Determine the failure mechanism
The physical, chemical, or electrical root cause of the failure must be identified – this is the essence of root‑cause analysis.
4. Propose corrective actions
Based on the root‑cause analysis, corrective measures should be proposed for design, manufacturing processes, or material selection to prevent recurrence of similar issues.
5. Support liability determination
In supply‑chain management, failure analysis provides technical evidence for responsibility assignment and claims.
6. Improve product reliability
By continuously solving failure problems and accumulating experience, product service life and stability can ultimately be enhanced.
Common Failure Modes and Causes
Based on the location and mechanism of failure, PCB failures can be categorised as follows.
1. Substrate Material and Laminate Failures
These failures relate to the PCB's base material and include:
Delamination or blistering – Separation between layers or between copper foil and the substrate. Causes may include insufficient bonding strength during lamination, moisture absorption during manufacturing, or high‑temperature, humid environments and thermal stress during subsequent use. Mismatch in the coefficient of thermal expansion (CTE) in the thickness direction can also exacerbate delamination.
CAF failure – Conductive Anodic Filament (CAF) is the growth of fine metallic filaments between adjacent conductors under high‑humidity and biased conditions, resulting in short circuits. This is a relatively hidden failure mode.
Warpage or twist – Bending or twisting of the board, usually related to non‑uniform materials, residual stress from lamination, or asymmetric board construction. Warpage affects soldering quality and in‑service reliability.
Thermal decomposition or carbonisation – Localised overcurrent or overheating can cause thermal decomposition of the substrate, degrading insulation performance. In severe cases, the substrate carbonises and becomes conductive, further expanding the failure.
2. Copper Trace and Pattern Failures
Open circuits – Trace fractures caused by over‑etching (resulting in traces that are too narrow), scratches during production, or thermal stress and electromigration during use.
Short circuits – Bridging between traces that should be isolated, caused by etching residues, foreign objects, electrochemical migration, or CAF.
High resistance – Traces that are narrower than designed, or contaminated/oxidised copper surfaces, resulting in abnormally high resistance.
Pad lifting or peeling – Insufficient bonding strength between the copper foil and the substrate, or excessive thermal stress during soldering, causing the pad to lift or separate from the board.
3. Via Wall and Plated Copper Failures
Via wall cracks or fractures – Poor drilling can introduce micro‑cracks; mechanical or thermal stress during subsequent use propagates these cracks, eventually causing the plated copper to split or break. CTE mismatch in the Z‑axis is another significant factor.
Voids or cracks in via copper – Inadequate plating process control results in insufficient copper thickness or voids in the via wall, affecting conductivity and mechanical strength.
Poor via‑to‑inner‑layer connection – Rough drilling, inadequate desmear, or poor electroless/electrolytic plating can lead to high resistance between the via copper and the inner‑layer traces, and in severe cases, open circuits.
Via wall separation – Separation between the plated copper and the substrate, compromising conduction reliability.
4. Surface Finish Failures
Solder non‑wetting or poor wetting – Oxidation, contamination, or ageing of the surface finish (e.g., OSP, ENIG, Immersion Silver, HASL) prevents solder from spreading properly.
Black pad phenomenon – Poor ENIG process control results in a brittle phosphorus‑rich layer between the nickel and the solder, leading to poor bond strength between the pad and the solder joint.
Micro‑voids – Oxidation of the copper surface beneath the immersion silver layer creates tiny voids during soldering, affecting solder‑joint reliability.
Tin whisker growth – Internal stress in pure tin or tin‑based coatings can cause fine whiskers to grow, potentially shorting adjacent conductors.
5. Solder Joint Failures
Cold solder or insufficient wetting – Poor solderability of the pad or component lead, or insufficient heat during soldering, prevents the solder from fully melting and wetting, resulting in weak connections.
Solder joint cracking – Mechanical shock, thermal‑cycle fatigue stress, or brittle solder alloys cause cracks to develop in solder joints during service.
Electromigration – Under high current density, metal atoms within the solder joint migrate under the influence of a strong electric field, creating voids or causing open circuits.
6. External Factors
Mechanical damage – Impact, vibration, bending, or other external forces cause cracks or fractures in the PCB.
Electrical overstress – Voltages or currents exceeding the design limits cause overheating, burnout, or insulation breakdown.
Environmental factors – Moisture, corrosive atmospheres, temperature cycling, radiation, and other environmental conditions beyond design expectations accelerate the failure process.
Assembly stress – Improper handling during rework or assembly introduces additional thermal or mechanical stress.
Standard Failure Analysis Workflow
A structured failure analysis typically follows a sequence from non‑destructive to destructive techniques, preserving as much original information as possible.
Step 1: Information Gathering
Before starting the analysis, collect the following information:
Detailed description of the failure symptom, including time, location, and how it occurred.
Relevant test data, such as electrical test reports and environmental test results.
PCB design data, including Gerber files, bill of materials, and stack‑up details.
Manufacturing and assembly process information.
Product application environment and actual usage history.
Step 2: Electrical Re‑creation and Localisation
Use multimeters, oscilloscopes, flying‑probe testers, and other equipment to confirm whether the failure is reproducible. With the circuit schematic and PCB layout, narrow down the problem to a specific net, component, or area. For heating or leakage issues, tools such as infrared thermal cameras can be used for localisation.
Step 3: Non‑Destructive Inspection
Visual inspection – Use the naked eye or an optical microscope to observe visible damage, including charring, discoloration, cracks, foreign matter, corrosion, blistering, and warpage.
X‑ray inspection – Examine internal structures using X‑ray transmission to detect inter‑layer traces, voids or cracks in vias, internal foreign objects, and solder‑joint conditions. 2D X‑ray provides planar information, while 3D CT scanning reveals three‑dimensional structures.
Scanning Acoustic Microscopy (SAM) – Utilises the reflection of ultrasonic waves at material interfaces to detect hidden delamination, voids, and cracks.
Step 4: Semi‑Destructive and Destructive Inspection
Cross‑section analysis – Using metallographic sectioning, the failure site is cut out, mounted, ground, and polished. Optical or scanning electron microscopy is then used to examine microstructures such as via‑wall copper thickness, plating quality, inter‑layer bonding, and crack propagation. This is a core technique for analysing vias, plating, and inter‑layer issues.
Surface elemental analysis – Use scanning electron microscopy (SEM) to observe micro‑morphology, combined with energy‑dispersive X‑ray spectroscopy (EDS/EDX) to analyse the elemental composition of the failure area, identifying contaminants, migrated materials, or corrosion products. For surface‑specific analysis, Auger Electron Spectroscopy (AES) or Secondary Ion Mass Spectrometry (SIMS) can be used.
Thermal analysis – Use Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC) to determine the glass‑transition temperature (Tg) of the substrate, and Thermomechanical Analysis (TMA) to measure the CTE.
Other tests – Depending on specific needs, peel‑strength testing, ionic contamination testing, solderability testing, etc., may also be performed.
Step 5: Root‑Cause Analysis and Mechanism Confirmation
Integrate all observations, test data, and inspection results. Using knowledge of materials science, microelectronics, and reliability engineering, determine the physical or chemical mechanism of failure. Apply the process of elimination to identify the most direct and fundamental root cause.
Example: If a via shows high resistance, cross‑sectioning reveals severe voids in the via copper, and EDS analysis detects residual contaminants in the void area – and the via is located near the board edge where moisture ingress is likely – it can be inferred that poor plating caused the voids, and contaminants combined with moisture accelerated the failure process.
Step 6: Reporting and Recommendations
The analysis report should clearly describe the failure symptom, the analytical process, observations, and the root‑cause conclusion. Based on this, corrective recommendations should be made:
Design improvements – Optimise layout to avoid hot‑spot concentration; improve thermal management; increase trace and pad spacing to prevent CAF; adjust stack‑up; select appropriate materials and surface finishes.
Manufacturing process improvements – Optimise drilling, plating, and lamination parameters; enhance process cleanliness controls; improve surface‑finish processes.
Material selection – Choose materials with higher Tg, better CAF resistance, and more reliable surface finishes.
Assembly and application – Optimise reflow and wave‑soldering temperature profiles; improve temperature and humidity control in storage and handling; avoid over‑stress conditions in use.
Key Considerations
1. Maintain a complete evidence chain
Failure areas are typically very small, and the analysis process itself may destroy the sample. Therefore, thorough non‑destructive inspection and documentation must be completed before any destructive testing.
2. Adopt a systematic mindset
Failure analysis cannot focus on a single aspect alone; it requires a comprehensive consideration of design, materials, manufacturing, assembly, application environment, and other factors.
3. Emphasise experience accumulation
The ability to anticipate failure modes and quickly select appropriate analytical methods and instruments comes from long‑term practical experience.
4. Conduct simulation verification when necessary
For complex failure cases, it is sometimes necessary to experimentally simulate failure conditions to validate the inferred root cause.
Conclusion
PCB failure analysis is a comprehensive discipline integrating electrical testing, physical analysis, and chemical analysis. Through a rigorous, scientifically structured analytical process and appropriate detection methods, the root cause of failure can be revealed – thereby driving continuous improvement in design, manufacturing, and application. For technical personnel engaged in R&D, production, and quality management of electronic products, mastering the basic concepts and methods of failure analysis is an essential competency for improving product reliability.
About Maxipcb