Electromagnetic compatibility (EMC) design typically employs various control techniques. In general, the closer the control is applied to the EMI source, the lower the cost of achieving EMI control. Integrated circuit (IC) chips on the PCB are the primary sources of EMI energy. Therefore, a thorough understanding of the internal characteristics of IC chips can simplify EMI control in PCB and system‑level design.
When considering EMI control, design engineers and PCB layout engineers should first consider the selection of the IC chips. Certain IC features – such as package type, bias voltage, and chip process technology (e.g., CMOS, ECL) – have a significant impact on electromagnetic interference. This article focuses on the impact of ICs on EMI control.
Sources of EMI in Integrated Circuits
The main sources of EMI from ICs on a PCB include:
The square‑wave signal generated at the output when a digital IC transitions from logic high to low or from logic low to high.
EMI signal voltages and currents.
Electric and magnetic fields.
The inherent capacitance and inductance of the chip itself.
The square‑wave signal at the output of an IC chip contains a wide range of sinusoidal harmonic components, which constitute the EMI frequencies of concern to engineers. The highest EMI frequency, also known as the EMI emission bandwidth, is a function of the signal rise time, not the signal frequency.
The formula for calculating the EMI emission bandwidth is:
f = 0.35 / Tr
where *f* is the frequency in GHz, and Tr is the signal rise time or fall time in nanoseconds.
From this formula, it can be seen that if the switching frequency of a circuit is 50 MHz and the rise time of the IC chip used is 1 ns, the highest EMI emission frequency of that circuit will reach 350 MHz – far exceeding the switching frequency. If the rise time is 5 ps, the highest EMI emission frequency would be as high as 700 MHz.
Every voltage in a circuit corresponds to a certain current, and conversely, every current corresponds to a voltage. When the IC output transitions between logic high and low, these signal voltages and currents generate electric and magnetic fields. The highest frequency of these fields is the emission bandwidth. The strength of the electric and magnetic fields, as well as the percentage of radiated energy, depends not only on the signal rise time but also on how well the capacitance and inductance along the signal path from the source to the load are controlled. The signal source is located inside the IC, while the load is inside another IC – which may or may not be on the same PCB. To effectively control EMI, it is necessary to pay attention not only to the capacitance and inductance of the IC chip itself but also to the capacitance and inductance present on the PCB.
When the coupling between the signal voltage and its return path is weak, the circuit's capacitance decreases, weakening the suppression of the electric field and thereby increasing EMI. The same principle applies to current: if the coupling between the current and its return path is poor, the loop inductance increases, strengthening the magnetic field and ultimately increasing EMI. This illustrates that poor control of the electric field often leads to poor suppression of the magnetic field as well. The measures used to control electromagnetic fields in a circuit board are broadly similar to those used to suppress electromagnetic fields in an IC package. As with PCB design, the IC package design will significantly affect EMI.
A considerable portion of electromagnetic radiation in a circuit is caused by voltage transients on the power bus. When the IC's output stage transitions and drives the connected PCB trace to a logic "high," the IC draws current from the power supply to provide the energy required by the output stage. For the ultra‑high‑frequency currents generated by the IC's constant switching, the power bus – from the decoupling network on the PCB to the IC's output stage – is the path. If the output stage has a signal rise time of 1.0 ns, the IC must draw enough current from the power supply within that very short 1.0 ns period to drive the transmission line on the PCB. The voltage transient on the power bus depends on the inductance of the power bus path, the current drawn, and the current transfer time. The voltage transient is defined by the formula:
V = L × (di / dt)
where L is the inductance of the current path, di is the change in current during the signal rise time interval, and dt is the change in the current transfer time (the signal rise time).
Since the IC pins and internal circuitry are part of the power bus, and both the current draw and the output signal rise time depend to some extent on the IC's process technology, selecting an appropriate IC can largely control the three factors mentioned in the above formula.
The Role of Package Characteristics in EMI Control
An IC package typically includes the silicon chip, a small internal PCB, and pads. The silicon chip is mounted on the small internal PCB, with connections between the chip and the pads made via bonding wires (or, in some packages, via direct connections). The small PCB provides the connection between the signal and power nodes on the silicon chip and the corresponding pins on the IC package, thereby extending those nodes to the outside world. Consequently, the power and signal transmission paths include the silicon chip, the connections to the small PCB, the PCB traces, and the input/output pins of the IC package. How well the capacitance and inductance (corresponding to the electric and magnetic fields) are controlled depends largely on the overall transmission path design. Certain design features directly affect the capacitance and inductance of the entire IC package.
Consider the connection between the silicon chip and the internal small PCB. Many IC chips use bonding wires – extremely fine gold wires – to connect the silicon chip to the internal PCB. This technique is widely used because the coefficient of thermal expansion (CTE) of the silicon chip and that of the internal small PCB are similar. The chip itself is a silicon‑based device, and its CTE differs considerably from that of typical PCB materials such as epoxy resin. If the electrical connection points on the silicon chip were mounted directly onto the internal PCB, temperature changes inside the IC package during thermal cycling would cause expansion and contraction, and the connections would fail by fracture after a relatively short time. Bonding wires are a type of interconnection that can withstand such harsh conditions, accommodating significant flexure without breaking.
The drawback of bonding wires is that each signal or power line increases the loop area and thus increases inductance. A better design for achieving lower inductance is to make a direct connection between the silicon chip and the internal PCB – that is, the connection points of the silicon chip are bonded directly to the PCB pads. This requires the use of a special PCB substrate material with a very low coefficient of thermal expansion. Choosing such a material increases the overall cost of the IC chip, so chips using this technology are not common. However, if such a direct‑connection IC exists and is feasible for the design, it would be a good choice.
Generally speaking, in IC package design, reducing inductance and increasing the capacitance between signal and return paths – or between power and ground – is the primary consideration when selecting an IC chip. For example, among surface‑mount technologies, ICs with fine‑pitch packages should be preferred over those with wide‑pitch packages. Both types of surface‑mount packages are superior to through‑hole packages in this regard. BGA‑packaged ICs offer the lowest lead inductance of any commonly used package type. From the perspective of capacitance and inductance control, smaller packages and finer pitches generally always represent improved performance.
An important feature of lead‑frame design is pin assignment. Since the values of inductance and capacitance depend on the proximity between the signal or power line and its return path, an adequate number of return paths must be provided.
Power and ground pins should be assigned in pairs, with each power pin having a corresponding adjacent ground pin, and multiple such pairs should be distributed throughout the lead frame. Both of these features significantly reduce the loop inductance between power and ground, helping to reduce voltage transients on the power bus and thereby lowering EMI. Historically, many IC chips on the market have not fully adhered to these design rules, but IC designers and manufacturers are well aware of the benefits of this approach and are now paying more attention to power connections in new chip designs and releases.
Ideally, every signal pin should have an adjacent signal‑return pin (such as a ground pin). In reality, however, many IC manufacturers adopt other compromises. In BGA packages, an effective design approach is to place a signal‑return pin at the centre of every group of eight signal pins. In this arrangement, each signal is only one pin pitch away from its return path. For quad flat packages (QFPs) or other gull‑wing type packages, placing a return path at the centre of a signal group is impractical; even so, a signal‑return pin should be provided every four to six pins. It should be noted that different IC process technologies may use different signal‑return voltages. Some ICs use ground pins (e.g., TTL devices) as the return path, others use power pins (e.g., most ECL devices), and still others use both power and ground pins (e.g., most CMOS devices). Therefore, design engineers must be familiar with the logic family of the ICs used in the design and understand their relevant operating characteristics.
The proper distribution of power and ground pins in an IC chip not only reduces EMI but also greatly improves ground‑bounce performance. When a device driving a transmission line attempts to pull the line to a logic low, ground bounce may keep the line above the logic‑low threshold, potentially causing circuit failure or malfunction.
Another important issue in IC packages is the design of the internal PCB. The internal PCB is usually the largest component of the IC package. If the internal PCB is designed with strict control of capacitance and inductance, it will greatly improve the overall EMI performance of the system. For a two‑layer internal PCB, at a minimum, one layer should be a continuous ground plane, and the other layer should be used for power and signal routing. A four‑layer internal PCB is even better, with the two inner layers used for power and ground planes, and the outer layers for signal routing. Because the internal PCB is typically very thin, a four‑layer structure provides two high‑capacitance, low‑inductance routing layers, which are particularly suitable for power distribution and for I/O signals that require tight control. The low‑impedance plane layers greatly reduce voltage transients on the power bus, significantly improving EMI performance. Such controlled signal lines are beneficial not only for reducing EMI but also for ensuring the signal integrity of signals entering and leaving the IC.
About Maxipcb